Ask for ice cream( it is amazing !!!)
In the 30's, Al Capone let them use their own cheese as long as they didn't sell slices. They still don't. In 2012 I would like to just buy a slice from them.
Family staple on the UWS. Pizza is great and won't break the bank.
Pepperoni, mushroom & olive 16" Stick to the basics. Hard to beat.
The food is nice, but sadly the waitress was very rude, bad attitude all the time and that makes me don't go back again.
Their coal fired slices are the missing link of pizza. The clear middle ground between the old world Neapolitan pies and the modern New York slice.
"I suggest you get the plain pizza. It is great for families. Maybe you will go to Patsy's for your birthday." -James, age 7
More than just pizza - we also had salads, pasta and meat dishes - all very good.